The judge ruled from the bench in yesterday's hearing, and granted the State's Motion for Partial Summary Judgment as to Count 5, in all respects.
He has ordered James Catledge to comply with the Consent Order to Cease and Desist and make the rescission payments of about $1.9 mil. He also awarded pre-judgment interest of over $400,000, and levied a penalty of $10,000 for failure to comply with the Cease and Desist order. The judge also awarded a money judgment to the State as a means to help the State collect the money. The judgment is for slightly over $2.4 mil.
Site created to communicate with investors and alleged victims in the case of Idaho Department of Finance vs. Derek Elliott, the Elliott Group of Companies, James Catledge, and Impact Net Worth.
Thursday, November 11, 2010
Thursday, October 7, 2010
Hearing results
A hearing was held on various motions of the parties, at 3:00 PM on October 6, 2010. The result is that James Catledge and the Impact defendants have been ordered to respond to the Motion for Partial Summary Judgment filed by the Department.
Defendants are to file their response by October 27, 2010. The Department has a week to reply to that response, and the hearing on the Motion for Partial Summary Judgment is set for 3:00 PM on November 10, 2010.
Defendants are to file their response by October 27, 2010. The Department has a week to reply to that response, and the hearing on the Motion for Partial Summary Judgment is set for 3:00 PM on November 10, 2010.
Friday, September 10, 2010
Summary Judgment
The State has filed a motion for partial summary judgment, as to Count 5 of the Verified Complalint. This motion seeks a judgment that James Catledge and Impact violated the Consent Order to Cease and Desist. The State is asking for an order that Catledge and Impact obey the terms of the Consent Order, and that they be ordered to make rescission payments.
This motion is currently set for hearing on October 6, 2010, at 3:00 PM, in the Ada County Courthouse.
This motion is currently set for hearing on October 6, 2010, at 3:00 PM, in the Ada County Courthouse.
Tuesday, July 27, 2010
A flurry of motions
Defendants John Thomson, Steve Cabezud and Barbara Nagel recently obtained new counsel, Boise attorney Thomas Banducci.
The Department filed a Motion to Strike Answers of Thomson, Cabezud and Nagel, and asked the court to enter default, based on the defendants' failure to comply with the court's order compelling discovery and its order to show cause. Banducci has filed an opposition to this motion.
Banducci has also filed a motion to set aside the court's order deeming the Department's Requests for Admission as admitted, and has attempted to respond to the court's order to show cause. The Department has filed briefing opposing these two efforts, and has filed a motion to strike from the record parts of what defendants filed.
The hearing on the various motions is set for Monday, August 2, 2010, at 11:00 AM, in the Ada County courthouse.
The Department is still waiting for the judge to sign the stipulated order on Catledge's Motion for Protective Order, and we are also waiting for the judge to sign the documents to take a default judgment against Derek Elliott.
Update: Just received the judgment and permanent injunction against Elliott, and the order for the Protective Order. The Department was awarded a judgment amount against Derek Elliott and Sun Village Juan Dolio Associates in the amount of $2,653,880.65.
The Department filed a Motion to Strike Answers of Thomson, Cabezud and Nagel, and asked the court to enter default, based on the defendants' failure to comply with the court's order compelling discovery and its order to show cause. Banducci has filed an opposition to this motion.
Banducci has also filed a motion to set aside the court's order deeming the Department's Requests for Admission as admitted, and has attempted to respond to the court's order to show cause. The Department has filed briefing opposing these two efforts, and has filed a motion to strike from the record parts of what defendants filed.
The hearing on the various motions is set for Monday, August 2, 2010, at 11:00 AM, in the Ada County courthouse.
Update: Just received the judgment and permanent injunction against Elliott, and the order for the Protective Order. The Department was awarded a judgment amount against Derek Elliott and Sun Village Juan Dolio Associates in the amount of $2,653,880.65.
Monday, June 14, 2010
Motion for protective order
During the May 24th hearing on the State's Motion to Compel and Catledge's Motion for Stay, counsel for Catledge verbally converted their Motion to Stay to a Motion for Protective Order. The judge directed counsel to prepare a draft protective order.
Catledge's counsel and I have been negotiating the terms of the order. I expect we will reach some agreement and will submit that to the judge for his review and approval.
The judge did not rule on the State's Motion to Compel, as that was essentially subsumed by the Motion for Protective Order. Counsel are also negotiating terms of future discovery.
Catledge's counsel and I have been negotiating the terms of the order. I expect we will reach some agreement and will submit that to the judge for his review and approval.
The judge did not rule on the State's Motion to Compel, as that was essentially subsumed by the Motion for Protective Order. Counsel are also negotiating terms of future discovery.
Monday, May 17, 2010
Motion to compel, motion for stay
The Department has filed a motion to compel Mr. Catledge to respond to discovery filed by the Department in August, 2009. This motion is set for hearing on Monday, May 24, 2010, at 1:30 PM in Judge Wilper's courtroom.
Catledge and the Impact Defendants have filed an opposition to the State's motion, and have also filed a motion requesting a temporary stay of the State's case. The gist of Catledge's motion for a stay is that he is under investigation by the FBI and the US Attorney's Office in the Northern District of California, and he believes the State's action should be stayed until the criminal action (if any comes out of the investigation) is resolved.
This issue will also be heard on May 24th.
Catledge and the Impact Defendants have filed an opposition to the State's motion, and have also filed a motion requesting a temporary stay of the State's case. The gist of Catledge's motion for a stay is that he is under investigation by the FBI and the US Attorney's Office in the Northern District of California, and he believes the State's action should be stayed until the criminal action (if any comes out of the investigation) is resolved.
This issue will also be heard on May 24th.
Tuesday, March 23, 2010
Barbara Nagel files for bankruptcy protection
Barbara Nagel has now filed for bankruptcy protection in California.
Thursday, March 18, 2010
Another bankruptcy
The Department discovered today that Defendant John Thomson filed for bankruptcy on march 12, 2010, in Utah, case # 10-22990. A notice of the bankruptcy was filed with the District Court in Idaho in this action, and the Court entered a civil disposition regarding Thomson based on the stay.
The Department is considering its response to these developments.
The Department is considering its response to these developments.
Monday, March 15, 2010
Motion to withdraw - Monday, April 5, 2010, 2:30 PM.
At the hearing on the Department's motion for sanctions, and to vacate the order quashing the subpoena of Wells Fargo records, no party other than the Department showed up.
The Judge vacated his order quashing the subpoena. The State is now free to proceed with the production.
As a sanction for violating his order to provide discovery, the judge "deemed admitted" the Requests for Admission previously filed by the State. He also directed me to provide a proposed order giving defendants Thomson, Cabezud and Nagel 10 days to show cause why their answers should not be stricken. I have sent him the proposed order, and copied it to the other parties.
Counsel for Thomson, Cabezud and Nagel filed various motions on Friday, March 12. He has asserted the bankruptcy stay in an effort to avoid the actions against Cabezud. He has moved for a protective order to prevent the depositions of Thomson, Cabezud and Nagel that are currently set for the end of this month. He moved to withdraw as counsel for the three defendants. He also objected to the proposed order to show cause.
Counsel for defendants noticed the motion to withdraw for Monday, April 5, 2010, at 2:30 PM.
The Judge vacated his order quashing the subpoena. The State is now free to proceed with the production.
As a sanction for violating his order to provide discovery, the judge "deemed admitted" the Requests for Admission previously filed by the State. He also directed me to provide a proposed order giving defendants Thomson, Cabezud and Nagel 10 days to show cause why their answers should not be stricken. I have sent him the proposed order, and copied it to the other parties.
Counsel for Thomson, Cabezud and Nagel filed various motions on Friday, March 12. He has asserted the bankruptcy stay in an effort to avoid the actions against Cabezud. He has moved for a protective order to prevent the depositions of Thomson, Cabezud and Nagel that are currently set for the end of this month. He moved to withdraw as counsel for the three defendants. He also objected to the proposed order to show cause.
Counsel for defendants noticed the motion to withdraw for Monday, April 5, 2010, at 2:30 PM.
Tuesday, March 2, 2010
Catledge answer; motion to quash
James Catledge and the Impact defendants filed an Answer on February 25, 2010.
Counsel for Defendants Thomson, Cabezud and Nagel filed a petition to quash a subpoena issued by the Department to Wells Fargo Bank, seeking bank records related to James Catledge and various Impact and Impact-related entities. The judge granted that motion to quash. The Department has moved to vacate the order to quash so that it can obtain the records. That motion is also currently set for March 8th, along with the motion for sanctions.
Counsel for Defendants Thomson, Cabezud and Nagel filed a petition to quash a subpoena issued by the Department to Wells Fargo Bank, seeking bank records related to James Catledge and various Impact and Impact-related entities. The judge granted that motion to quash. The Department has moved to vacate the order to quash so that it can obtain the records. That motion is also currently set for March 8th, along with the motion for sanctions.
Thursday, February 18, 2010
Motion for Sanctions
The Department has filed a Motion for Sanctions against Defendants Thomson, Cabezud, and Nagel. The Court ordered that the Defendants provide discovery to the Department. Thomson and Cabezud did not respond at all, and therefor the Department believes they are in violation of the Court's Order to respond. Ms. Nagel did provide a substantial number of documents, but failed to otherwise respond to the discovery. As punishment for violating the Order, the Department is seeking sanctions.
The Hearing on the Motion for Sanctions is set for March 8th, 2010, at 2 PM.
The Department received notice this week that Defendant Cabezud has filed for Chapter 7 bankruptcy protection in California. Case No. 10-10419 AJ 7.
The Hearing on the Motion for Sanctions is set for March 8th, 2010, at 2 PM.
The Department received notice this week that Defendant Cabezud has filed for Chapter 7 bankruptcy protection in California. Case No. 10-10419 AJ 7.
Tuesday, February 16, 2010
David Brimley default judgment
When the Diaz and Nevin firms withdrew as counsel for James Catledge and David Brimley, they has a set time to obtain new counsel or otherwise appear in the action. Brimley never appeared, so the Department moved for entry of default against him. Having obtained default, the Department also was able to get a default judgment.
You can see a copy here.
You can see a copy here.
Wednesday, February 3, 2010
Tuesday, February 2, 2010
Motion to compel
The State scheduled a Motion to Compel Discovery from Defendants Thomson, Nagel and Cabezud, which was heard on Friday, January 29. The Judge signed an order compelling those Defendants to produce the requested discovery no later than February 12, 2010.
There are no other hearings pending at this time.
There are no other hearings pending at this time.
Wednesday, December 23, 2009
Motion to Dismiss Denied
The Department received today Judge Wilper's Order Denying Catledge's and Impact's Motion to Dismiss. He ruled 1) that the case is not barred by the statute of limitations contained in Idaho Code Sec. 30-14-509; 2) that the complaint was pled with sufficient particularity; and 3) that the Department did not fail to join indispensable parties.
Catledge and Impact must now file an Answer and the case can proceed. For various reasons, the deadline for filing the Answer is not set in stone, so I cannot give that date at this time.
We will post a copy of the Order a bit later.
Catledge and Impact must now file an Answer and the case can proceed. For various reasons, the deadline for filing the Answer is not set in stone, so I cannot give that date at this time.
We will post a copy of the Order a bit later.
Monday, November 30, 2009
Motion to compel
The Department of Finance has filed a motion to compel discovery against Barbara Nagel, Steve Cabezud, and John Thomson. We filed our discovery requests in August, and they have never responded.
The motion is set for hearing on December 14, 2009, at 11:00 AM, in the Fourth District courthouse, in Boise.
The judge has not yet ruled on Impact's Motion to Dismiss.
Update: The motion to compel was postponed due to a potential conflict that arose with the date. Unless an arrangement can be reached with counsel for defendants, we will re-set the motion for hearing.
There have been no other new developments.
The motion is set for hearing on December 14, 2009, at 11:00 AM, in the Fourth District courthouse, in Boise.
The judge has not yet ruled on Impact's Motion to Dismiss.
Update: The motion to compel was postponed due to a potential conflict that arose with the date. Unless an arrangement can be reached with counsel for defendants, we will re-set the motion for hearing.
There have been no other new developments.
Tuesday, November 24, 2009
New Catledge counsel
James Catledge and his Impact companies have retained new local counsel; Monte N. Stewart of the Boise firm Belnap Law, PLLC. So far, no other out-of-state counsel has requested admission.
Mr. Stewart has substituted in, thus rendering the motion to withdraw moot as to Catledge and the Impact companies. The motion is still pending as to David Brimley.
With the substitution of counsel, we should be able to proceed without further delays. As of today, the judge has not ruled on the pending motion to dismiss, or the pending motion for reconsideration.
Mr. Stewart has substituted in, thus rendering the motion to withdraw moot as to Catledge and the Impact companies. The motion is still pending as to David Brimley.
With the substitution of counsel, we should be able to proceed without further delays. As of today, the judge has not ruled on the pending motion to dismiss, or the pending motion for reconsideration.
Tuesday, November 3, 2009
Hearing result
At the hearing held on Monday, November 2, 2009, I moved to vacate the hearing on the motion to compel, until such time as new counsel appears, and the judge granted that.
Attorney Mike Diaz appeared by phone, and informed the court that he had been contacted on October 15, 2009 by Nevada (I think) attorney Rob Graham who stated he was taking over the Catledge cases. Diaz said they've now withdrawn from all Catledge cases.
The judge took both the Motion to Dismiss and the Motion to Withdraw under advisement. I had requested that he rule on the Motion to Dismiss as a means to avoid delay if new counsel were to appear and want to contest that motion.
The judge is considering whether to grant the Motion to Withdraw now and then wait to rule on the Motion to Dismiss, or whether to rule on the Motion to Dismiss and then grant the Motion to Withdraw. I argued that the former exposes us to additional delay, and the latter will help move the case along.
The judge said he'd try to rule within 30 days. Once he signs the Order Granting Withdrawal, Catledge will have an additional 20 days to appear either through new counsel, or pro se.
Attorney Mike Diaz appeared by phone, and informed the court that he had been contacted on October 15, 2009 by Nevada (I think) attorney Rob Graham who stated he was taking over the Catledge cases. Diaz said they've now withdrawn from all Catledge cases.
The judge took both the Motion to Dismiss and the Motion to Withdraw under advisement. I had requested that he rule on the Motion to Dismiss as a means to avoid delay if new counsel were to appear and want to contest that motion.
The judge is considering whether to grant the Motion to Withdraw now and then wait to rule on the Motion to Dismiss, or whether to rule on the Motion to Dismiss and then grant the Motion to Withdraw. I argued that the former exposes us to additional delay, and the latter will help move the case along.
The judge said he'd try to rule within 30 days. Once he signs the Order Granting Withdrawal, Catledge will have an additional 20 days to appear either through new counsel, or pro se.
Friday, October 23, 2009
Motion to withdraw
On Friday, October 23, 2009, the two law firms representing James Catledge and the Impact business entities filed a motion to withdraw as counsel. They have set that motion to be heard on November 2, 2009, along with the other two pending motions.
Thursday, October 22, 2009
Comments
We have changed the comment section to allow anonymous comments. Inappropriate comments will be deleted.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)